How Firm Baby Mattress Should Be

Home   /   How Firm Baby Mattress Should Be

How Firm is Firm Enough for a Baby Crib Mattress?

How Firm is Firm Enough for a Baby Crib Mattress?

I’ve seen several blogs and forums where people talk and ask questions about how firm a crib mattress should be. One person said “If it feels good to me, it’s okay for my baby.” Is that a good rule of thumb?

In fact, it’s not – unless you like a very firm mattress. Because babies are still growing, their spines and bones need more support than we do.

While there are no precise rules about crib mattress firmness, there are solid enough guidelines to help you choose the right one.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) recommends that a baby mattress be firm and flat.

Consumer Reports recommends buying the firmest mattress you can find. In fact, they address the exact comment made by the person on the forum: “Don’t worry that it may feel too firm. If it feels good to you, it’s too soft for your baby,"

To test a crib mattress to determine whether it’s firm enough, Consumer Reports suggests you “Press on the mattress in the center and at the edges. It should snap back readily and should not conform to the shape of your hand.”

In Naturepedic baby crib mattresses, our organic cotton batting makes the mattress surface comfortable without sacrificing firmness. Babies are pretty cozy on our mattresses and they routinely sleep through the night. Soft, comfortable and firm – just right!

The Best Baby Crib Mattresses

Best Parent-Approved Crib Mattress

Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress

Why we picked it

  • Bed bug and dust mite resistant
  • Easy to clean with a damp cloth or sponge to quickly remove messes
  • Made with non-toxic materials for a safe, healthy sleep

Best Designed Crib Mattress

Nook Crib Mattress

Why we picked it

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a dual-sided sleep system
  • Made free of harsh chemicals and toxins to keep your baby safe
  • Waterproof, flame resistant crib mattress with machine washable wrap

Best Infant to Toddler Crib Mattress

Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Why we picked it

  • Fights snugly into standard cribs to reduce risks and sleep hazards including the baby’s arms and legs getting stuck
  • Designed to meet both infant and toddler sleep needs with dual-sleep sides to fit both infant and toddler beds
  • Comes with a lifetime warranty

The Best Baby Crib Mattresses

A full security system may be the peace of mind you and your loved ones need to sleep better.

5 Best Baby Mattresses of 2019

  • Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress –Best Parent-Approved
  • Nook Crib Mattress –Best Designed Crib Mattress
  • Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress –Best Infant to Toddler Crib Mattress
  • Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed –Most Green Materials
  • LULLABY EARTH Baby Crib Mattress –Easiest Mattress to Clean

Compare Top Baby Mattresses

1. Moonlight Slumber Crib Mattress

Our take

This Moonlight Slumber crib mattress grows with your baby to the toddler stage with a dual-sided sleep system. The mattress is made with high-density foam for infancy stages and certified CertiPUR-US foam. Simply clean this mattress with a damp cloth to easily wipe away any messes without leaving any stains. It’s designed without flame retardants and is made with double-stretch knit fabric for a long-lasting crib mattress.*Although Moonlight Slumber’s website does not list polyurethane as an included material, Safety.com experts contacted a Moonlight Slumber representative who confirmed that polyurethane is a material used for the mattress to be waterproof.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes SafeSewn seams to be dust mite and bed bug resistant
  • Waterproof, flame resistant and hypoallergenic

2. Nook Crib Mattress

Our take

The Nook Sleep Pebble Air is an all-in-one crib mattress that doesn’t require a mattress pad or cover. Its light-as-a-feather design keeps the mattress breathable to help your baby sleep comfortably. The mattress includes zinc guards to protect your baby against any built up germs for a clean and safe mattress. The Pebble Air comes in three colors to find the best fit your nursery design.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a dual-sided sleep system
  • Made free of harsh chemicals and toxins to keep your baby safe
  • Waterproof, flame resistant crib mattress with machine washable wrap

3. Colgate Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Our take

This Colgate crib mattress fits all standard cribs and toddler beds. The light and airy mattress design make it easy to flip when your infant grows into a toddler. It’s made with sustainable plant oils and meets safety requirements from the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) to keep your baby safe from flammable materials.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Made with Certified Organic cotton mattress cover and CertiPUR certified safe foam
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals

4. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Our take

This Newton Baby light crib mattress is made with 100 percent recyclable materials. It’s designed to fit most standard cribs for a light, safe sleep. The Newton mattress uses Breathe-Thru Technology to reduce the risk of suffocation and breathing carbon dioxide by allowing the mattress’ air to flow freely. This mattress comes in four colors to best fit your nursery design.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed with an air core for air to easily pass for a light, breathable sleep
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Designed with a washable 3D spacer cover to reduce the worry of stains or mold while allowing air to flow freely

5. LULLABY EARTH Baby Crib Mattress

Our take

The Lullaby Earth crib mattress is flat with firm edges to fit standard cribs safely. It’s made to allow air to flow 360-degree under your infant with ease. The crib mattress is created with firm edges to avoid your baby from getting stuck in the space between the mattress and crib frame. Simply wash the removable mattress pad to remove any messes without any stains left behind.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed with 3D fabric to allow mattress air to flow freely
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Waterproof and flame resistant crib mattress

6. Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Our take

This long-lasting Milliard crib mattress is designed with five inches of high-quality foam to avoid it sinking over time. It includes a mattress cover that easily wipes away stains and messes. The mattress was made with your infant’s safety in mind – free of toxins and harsh chemicals for safe and serene sleeping.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed with a density of 28D to keep your infant from sinking into the crib mattress and prevent SIDS
  • Includes a removable, waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • Waterproof and flame resistant crib mattress

7. Safety 1st Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Our take

Safety 1st designed this lightweight crib mattress with high-quality foam to prevent your infant from sinking while sleeping. The mattress is water and flame resistant to keep your baby safe and sound while sleeping. This mattress comes in three colors to best fit your nursery design.

Stand-out features include

  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a 100% vinyl mattress cover that easily wipes away stains and messes
  • 5-year limited warranty

8. Sealy Toddler and Baby Crib Mattress

Our take

The Sealy crib mattress uses 150 steel coils and border rods to fit your crib for your baby to sleep safely. The mattress is designed with four layers for a firm, safe slumber. It includes a waterproof mattress cover to withstand water, moisture and mildew.

Stand-out features include

  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Uses lock-stitched binding to protect the crib mattress from odors and stains
  • 10-year warranty

9. Graco Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Our take

This Graco crib mattress is made with five inches high-quality foam. It’s made with a polyurethane foam base for light and airy sleep. It’s made free from chemicals including phthalates and lead for a safe crib mattress that works for both infant and toddler growth stages. Graco’s crib mattress fits into a lightweight box to easily unpack for your convenience.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes a removable, waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals

10. Dream On Me Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Our take

This Dream On Me 2-in-1 crib mattress is easy to clean messes and stains with only warm water and soap. It’s designed for both infants and toddlers with six inches of firm foam and one inch of light and comfy foam for newborns to sleep happily and safely. The crib mattress cover is waterproof and hypoallergenic to reduce the worry of mold and mildew over time.

Stand-out features include

  • Meets Federal Flammability Standards by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • 15-year warranty

11. Beautyrest 2-in-1 Crib and Toddler Mattress

Our take

The Beautyrest crib mattress uses 231 high-quality coil springs for a night of safe, firm sleep. Flip the mattress when your baby grows for toddlers to sleep safely with foam. The mattress is hypoallergenic to reduce the worry of mold and mildew in the mattress. It also includes a fire resistant wrap to protect the mattress and your baby.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • GREENGUARD GOLD and CertiPUR-US Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a woven, waterproof mattress cover with a stain-resistant design

12. Kolcraft Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress

Our take

The Kolcraft Pure Sleep crib mattress is designed to grow with your infant to the toddler years using a dual-sleep design. It’s made with 150 high-quality coils to avoid the common concern of your baby sinking into the mattress. This mattress’ design makes it easy to clean with a damp cloth to remove and messes or stains for your baby to enjoy their sleep.

Stand-out features include

  • GREENGUARD GOLD and CertiPUR-US Certified to be free of harsh chemicals
  • Includes a breathable, easy to clean waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • 10-year warranty

13. My Green Mattress Crib Mattress

Our take

This Emily crib mattress is made with a natural, 100% organically processed, and made with eco wool. The mattress can easily be flipped to prevent too much wear and tear on one side for a long-lasting crib mattress. It’s free of polyurethane foams to avoid the risk of your infant being exposed to toxins and harmful chemicals during sleep.

Stand-out features include

  • Made with Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS) cotton and 150 high-quality coil springs
  • Lead-free certified by the UL Laboratories for a crib mattress free of harsh chemicals
  • 10-year warranty

14. Babyletto Non-Toxic Crib Mattress

Our take

The Babyletto Pure Core mattress was designed with your baby’s safety in mind. It is a vegan, non-toxic crib mattress free of flame retardants or dyes. The mattress has both a firm and soft side to match your baby’s sleep needs from infant to toddler growth stages for many nights of free of harsh chemicals when sleeping.

Stand-out features include

  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Includes a vinyl-free, removable, easy to clean waterproof cover to protect your crib mattress
  • 10-year warranty

15. Naturepedic Dual Firmness Crib Mattress

Our take

The Naturepedic crib mattress uses 150 heavy-duty coils for infants to have firm support while sleeping. It includes square corners for your baby to sleep safely without risk of arms or legs getting stuck in tight corners. The crib mattress is made from a GOTS-certified brand that only uses GOTS-approved materials for your baby’s safety.

Stand-out features include

  • Made with 100% USA organic cotton fabric and GOTS-certified materials
  • Designed for both infants and toddlers with a double-sided mattress
  • Square edges for the crib mattress to fit tightly and securely into any standard crib

Showing 5 of 15 products

Showing 15 of 15 products

Factors to Consider Before Buying a Crib Mattress

Use a waterproof cover

Your crib mattress cover should be waterproof to resist any accidents or spills that are common with babies. If the mattress or mattress cover is not waterproof, there’s an increased likelihood of mold or mildew building over time from the retained moisture. Mold can lead to health issues especially if your baby has asthma or allergies. Even if your mattress is designed to resist moisture, regularly inspect the crib mattress appearance and smell.

The Best Crib Mattresses for Baby

Ever pressed down on a crib mattress to test out the comfort factor? If so, your first thought might have been,It’s so hard — is my baby actually going to be able to sleep on this?

Yes, she will. More than that, though, it’s essential that your baby’s crib mattress be anything but plush. Although the following statistic can be tough to think about, approximately 3,600 babies die suddenly and unexpectedly every year in the U.S. from Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS). "Safe sleep practices are the best way to reduce the risk of this happening,” says Rachel Y. Moon, M.D., an investigator with the Child Health Research Center at the University of Virginia School of Medicine.

In addition to following safe sleep practices such as "back to sleep" and keeping soft bedding like blankets, pillows and crib bumpers out of the crib, having a well-designed and firm crib mattress is important to prevent SIDS.

What to look for in a crib mattress

“Crib mattresses should be firm, which means hard,” says Dr. Moon. “A hard mattress will not mold to the shape of the baby. Just becauseyouwould prefer a softer mattress does not mean that your baby would."

You’ll also want to make sure that the mattress fits snugly into the crib frame, adds Dr. Moon, as gaps between the rails and mattress can also pose a safety hazard.

Types of crib mattresses

In addition to essential safety features, there are a few other details you might consider when shopping for a crib mattress.

Dual-sided:Some crib mattresses are dual-sided, meaning they are designed to be firm on one side for infant sleeping and then can be turned over for a slightly softer sleep surface once your little one is a toddler. This certainly gives you more mileage from the mattress, but note that many toddlers remain content sleeping on firm mattresses for years.

Breatheable materials:You may find that some crib mattress brands advertise their “breathable” materials (like mesh), which can mean they don’t trap as much heat, lessening the risk of major baby sweat. Remember, though, that even with a “breathable” mattress, baby still needs to be put down on her back to go to sleep.

Green Guard certification:For some parents, it’s important that their baby’s crib mattress has Green Guard certification, which is used to identify products made from materials that give off low or no emissions of potentially harmful chemicals called VOCs.

Mess-proofing:Mattresses are usually made with a few different layers, including a core (often foam) topped with a barrier layer (to prevent liquids from seeping in) and a top cover (e.g. cotton, polyester or a blend) that may be water- or allergy-proof for added peace of mind (and cleanliness). What you choose depends on your baby’s needs and what qualities you deem most important.

This can seem like a lot to think about, but don’t worry: you can — and will — find the right crib mattress for baby.

Here, the best baby crib mattresses for your little one.

Just so you know, What to Expect may earn commissions from shopping links. Why trust our product recommendations?

The 6 Highest Rated Crib Mattress Picks For 2020

Transparency Disclosure– We may receive a referral fee (at no additional cost to the buyer) for products purchased through the links on our site or other applicable pages. To learn more, please read our full disclosure pagehere . We also encourage you to read about how we may research and/or test Products here .

Nothing on this website is intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. You should always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. The contents of this website are for informational purposes only.

Do you think that children deserve the best possible care and products we can afford?

One of the most important things in the healthy development of your child is a good sleep. Proper bedding systems should help your baby to sleep well, and provide necessary support for their spine and neck.

If you are a parent looking for theultimatecrib mattress for your babyor toddler, choosing a good one is not an easy task. According to American Academy of Pediatrics many parents put their babies in unsafe sleeping conditions.

Top 6 Baby Mattresses Compared

  • Type: Memory Foam
  • Height: 5"
  • Waterproof: Yes
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Innerspring
  • Height: 6"
  • Waterproof: Yes
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hypo-Allergenic Foam
  • Height: 5"
  • Waterproof: Yes
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Innerspring
  • Height: 2.5"
  • Waterproof: Yes
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Memory Foam
  • Height: 5.5"
  • Waterproof: Yes
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Soybean Foam
  • Height: 5"
  • Waterproof: Yes

Important Things to Consider Before Buying (Buyer’s Guide)

Mattress Size

There is no right or wrong size. However, there are some regulations. The minimum size proposed by the government are in a range between 27 5/8″ to 28 5/8″ of width and 51 3/4″ to 53″ in length.The minimum size should be 27 1/4” x 51 5/8”and the bedding shouldn’t be thicker than 6 inches. The main rule is to have it fit the crib snug or moderately snug. The depth differs between 5 to 6 inches for coil crib type and 4 to 6 inches for foam-based products. Generally, if the gap is more than two fingers, the mattress is too small.

Choose the Material Wisely

A well-designed mattress should not only make your baby’s sleep more comfortable but should also give support for healthy spine development. The material is one of the most important aspects you should consider. Try to find along-term,comfortablebed since your child will probably sleep in a crib until the age of three. A mutual opinion on whether a foam or innerspring type is better for the baby doesn’t exist so you should carefully research before you buy.

Make sure to read our complete overview of memory foam mattresses and how it works.

Soft vs. Firm

Most of the experts are of the opinion that it’s better to have a firm crib mattress over a soft mattress. According to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the main death cause for infants in the United States of America is the SIDS – Sudden infant death syndrome.

This syndrome is caused by suffocation hazards which are a consequence of a soft sleeping surface. The bedding should snap back when you press it on the center and the thresholds. It shouldn’t conform to the baby’s head shape. The bed should be resilient enough to regain its shape quickly after applying hand pressure on it.

There are however various types which have two level of firmness foam. Onesoft for the toddlersand afirm one for infants. As far as infants are concerned, it’s safer to go with the firm rather than soft.

Is It Waterproof?

It might be a good idea to buy a waterproof mattress. A good indicator that it’s water resistant is adouble or triple ticking bolstered with nylon. This kind of content will also show high resistance to being teared up or soaking other solids or liquids.

Most of the products have covers made out of cotton and you might want to buy waterproof covers instead. You should also take notice of the airflow in and out. It should haveventing holeswhich will release the odor from leaking diapers.

Compliance Standards

Crib mattresses must pass certain standard requirements in order to be sold on the market in the United States. First of all, there are safety standards which are defined by the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission and the American Society for Testing and Materials. The US Federal government has regulations for cot bed standard sizes under the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 (CPSIA).

As far as the eco-friendly beds are concerned, there are many manufacturers who claim that their products are indeed friendly and safe for the environment. However, you should check if they have a certification called Oeko-Tex Standard 100. This is a globally accepted certification geared towards product safety with chemical and other stipulations.

Price Range

When it comes to buying a good baby cot mattress, you might not want to try bargain shopping, but you should also know that buying anoverpricedone won’t do you any good. The price is normally a good indicator of quality, but there are other important aspects you should look into.

According to numerous customers, a high-quality product will probably cost you between $90 and $350. Speaking of organic, they have a price tagsomewhere between $80 and $400.

These are some of the important factors that you should keep in mind, and we highlighted some of them in our guide with some of the best bed brands of 2020.

How Firm Should A Baby Crib Mattress Be?

October 13, 2017

One of the most important considerations parents should have about their baby’s mattress is the firmness level. While it’s tempting to want baby to have a cushion-soft surface that seems cozy to us as adults, it can be dangerous if a crib mattress is soft, floppy, or saggy.

Why You Don’t Want a Soft Mattress

For starters, babies’ bones are still developing and their bodies need much more support than ours do as adults. Adults may find comfort and support from a wide range of materials and firmness levels, but for babies it’s important to remember that firmer is always better. If it feels cozy to you, it’s probably too soft for your baby.

Babies, especially newborns and young infants, lack mobility and can’t get around very well. So they have a harder time lifting themselves up and repositioning like an adult would. If they stay on their back during sleep that’s one thing, but once they start rolling onto their tummies this can present a pretty serious risk. A softer mattress that is flexible at the edges can also increase the chance that arms or legs can get stuck between the mattress and the crib.

To reduce the risk of these potential hazards, it’s best to choose a firm crib mattress with firm edges. Safety recommendations also caution parents to place babies to sleep on their backs and to keep all soft materials (bedding, toys, etc.) out of the crib environment.

How Firm Should A Crib Mattress Be?

Consumer Reports recommends that you “Press on the mattress in the center and at the edges. It should snap back readily and should not conform to the shape of your hand.” So when you’re testing crib mattress firmness, feel free to put pressure on the mattress to make sure it resists the impression of your hand. It should feel a bit firmer than you’d think is comfortable. But trust us – babies need the firmer surface and sleep just fine!

The Ideal Firmness for a Crib Mattress

At Lullaby Earth, your baby’s safety is our priority. Our crib mattresses are made with firm, flat support, as recommended by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and also feature reinforced edges for a snug fit in the crib.

Our 2-stage or “dual firmness” crib mattresses have a firm side and a cushion firm side. When baby is around one year old you can switch to the cushion firm side for a little more cushion during the toddler years!

We do recommend you confirm with your pediatrician before flipping the mattress, since some babies may need a bit more time on the firmer infant side.

Add a Comment: