How Are Mattress Rated

Home   /   How Are Mattress Rated

10 Best Rated Mattresses – January 2020

Below are the Best rated mattresses for January 2020 based on customers reviews on various mattress categories. W e sifted through 1000s of customers reviews across the internet to read their responses . The ratings were based on comfort, heat dissipation, support, trial period, among other issues pertinent to a good night sleep. We love reviewing the mattresses and we may get commision if you buy following our links at no cost to you.

Cypress Bamboo Gel Mattress

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: 25 Years

Saatva

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: 15 Years

Nectar

TRIAL PERIOD: 365 Nights

WARRANTY: Forever™

Dreamcloud

TRIAL PERIOD: 365 Nights

WARRANTY: Everlong

Zenhaven

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: 20 Years

Winkbeds Plus

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: Lifetime

Casper

TRIAL PERIOD: 100 Nights

WARRANTY: 10 Years

Loom & Leaf

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: 15 Years

Novosbed

TRIAL PERIOD: 120 Nights

WARRANTY: 15 Years

Helix Sleep

TRIAL PERIOD: 100 Nights

WARRANTY: 10 Years

Best Mattress Reviews – 2020

Cypress Bamboo Gel Mattress – Best Overall Mattress

The Brentwood Home Cypress Bamboo Gel 13 mattress is made up of 3 layers of exceptional quality foam. It is built in the USA from a combination of gel memory foam, ventilated support foam, natural New Zealand wool which are wrapped in a removable bamboo infused zipper cover. The top layer which is for comfort and cooling is built with a 3.5-inch gel memory foam. This layer provides for primary comfort as it is responsible for pressure relief, body shape contouring, motion isolation and prevents mattress from retaining heat.Middle layer is built with a 2-inch ventilated support foam primarily for support and assisting the top layer in heat dissipation through improved air flow.Bottom layer, a 7.5-inch high density support foam act as the mattress foundation base which gives it its shape. Over the past few months, this mattress has been getting a lot of positive reviews and rating making it among the top mattresses overall.

Saatva – Best Innerspring Mattress

This mattress surpassed all the other innerspring mattresses to be our top choice. The reason behind this is that it is carefully crafted with tempered steel hourglass in the support coil and pocketed contouring coils on top. All these coils are wrapped by an eco-friendly memory foam that give you the comfort. Foam works in tandem with the coils to allow body shape contouring and comfort.

Its cover is made with an antimicrobial treatment, Guardin® on an organic cotton for ultimate sleep experience.

Saatva mattress is priced fairly especially if you consider durability, material quality and environment. All of its materials are eco-friendly, for instance; most of its coils are made with recycled steel. Also, the memory foam is infused with some corn oil or soy to provide for the best sleep experience.

Nectar – Best Memory Foam Mattress

Among memory foam mattresses, Nectar mattress has been a big name for a while and is still is among the best. It’s made with 4 layers of exceptional quality foam and a breathable and soft Tencel cover which is quilted on a 1-inch gel memory foam. Combination of the cover and the cooling gel provides for the ultra-cool sleeping comfort. Comfort layer which is below the cover is built with a 3-inch memory foam which is slow to respond and hence helping in pressure relief. Below this layer is a transition layer made with foams that are quicker to respond. The aim of this layer is to transition motion in to the base. Foundation layer is the very bottom layer constructed with a 6-inch high-density foam for stability and giving the mattress its shape. Considering the materials and workmanship of this mattress, Nectar has priced it fairly and is affordable.

Dreamcloud– Best Hybrid Mattress

DreamCloud mattress is a hotel-style mattress that will give you the ultimate comfort and support. It has a tufted pillow top that is soft, giving you the satisfaction like when you are on vacation. Dreamcloud is a hybrid mattress, built carefully to give you comfort and support. Its many parts designed to assist you in attaining the ultimate sleeping experience. It’s also a luxury mattress priced fairly which is affordable to average people. It stands 15” tall comprising of patented memory foam, hypoallergenic natural latex, gel infused memory foam, pocketed best Rest micro coils encased with foam and high-density memory foam. All these components are crafted together to form the best hybrid mattress.

Zenhaven – Best Latex Mattress

Zenhaven mattress is made with natural Talalay latex and offers a lot such as being chemical free, hypoallergenic and good heat regulator therefore you will sleep cool. If you like all-natural mattress, then this mattress is perfect for you as the many layers are built with the natural Talalay latex. Also, it is a perfect choice for those that sleep hot because the breathability of the Talalay latex makes temperature regulation easier. When it comes to durability, Zenhaven is the mattress to go for as it is well known that Talalay latex tend to endure for a long time. Zenhaven is priced fairly for a mattress with natural Talalay latex even though it is not the most affordable mattress.

Winkbeds Plus – Best Mattress For Heavy People

Winkbeds Plus is a mattress specifically designed for heavy people especially those over 300 lbs. Lighter people usually find this mattress slightly firm but can opt for the softer version. It has 3 firmness levels; softer, luxury firm and firmer you can choose from. Winkbeds plus is a hybrid mattress constructed from a combination of latex, foam and innersprings which stands at 14.5 inches high. From top to bottom, the mattress consists of the following layers; 1” proprietary gel foam, 2.5” latex foam, triple-zone pocketed coil system and high-density foam at the bottom for foundation. For a luxury mattress like Winkbeds, it is priced fairly compared to other mattresses of its kind.

Casper – Best Mattress For Side Sleepers

There have been updates to the Casper to include exciting new features that significantly improve the original model. This mattress is made out of premium foams and contains a special Zoned Support layer. It is perfect for side sleepers who are in search of a more comfortable sleeping experience where each part of their body is targeted in unique ways. When you are sleeping on your side, your core and hips are supported and won’t sink in as deep, and at the same time your upper body sinks into the mattress further, which means that your spine will be aligned comfortably and you will be provided with support and pressure relief exactly where you need it. Three different kinds of foams are used to construct the Zoned Support, and together they provide a nice lift to your hips, firm support for your lumbar region and gentle pressure relief for your shoulders.

Loom & Leaf – Best Mattress For Stomach Sleepers

This is the best mattress for those who sleep on their stomach. It is available in two different levels of firmness that provides sleepers with a good memory foam experience but without the feeling that your lumbar region and face are sinking too far into the mattress. It also helps to prevent your spine from getting out of alignment. There is gel infused foam contained in the Loom & Leaf mattress that works to regulate the temperature. That prevents any body heat from getting trapped the way it does with traditional foam mattresses. There is also an extra layer of gel which offers more cooling. The convoluted design and unique quilted cover of the first layer promote good airflow, and that helps you stay comfortable and sleep cooler.

Novosbed – Best Mattress For Back Sleepers

This bed-in-a-box memory mattress comes in three different firmness levels: Medium Firm, Medium, and Soft. Three different firmness levels are offered to cater to back sleepers who are at different weight levels, especially lightweight people who tend to prefer sleeping on a less firm mattress. The top part of the cover features a stretch-knit soft Tencel, which is a type of breathable material that is made out of wood pulp to offer outstanding moisture wicking. You can remove the cover and wash it in your washing machines, but the company does recommend that you hang up the cover to dry it. The base part of the cover is made of an upholstery-grade textile that is combined with a non-slip bottom. It is very convenient to use with an adjustable base. When the cover is included, the mattress is made of four levels of high-quality materials and is 11 inches in height.

Helix – ​Best Mattress For Back Pain

This is a hybrid mattress that comes in 9 different options so that every type of sleeper is accommodated perfectly. To ensure that you end up with the best mattress for your needs, Helix offers a sleep quiz to help you narrow down your choices depending on what your preferences are. Although there are several similarities that each of the mattresses share, they each have their very own distinct characteristics also so that each one is unique and a bit more appealing depending on what style of sleeping you use. You can either take the quick questionnaire or just choose the best mattress on your own. Each of the mattresses uses high-quality construction and materials. That includes a brand new 6-inch pocketed thick coil system that features reinforced edges. This is a noticeable improvement over the original Helix mattress. It provides each mattress with increased heat and airflow dissipation, improved perimeter durability, and better ideal support.

Factors To Consider When Shopping For A Good Mattress

Mattress shopping can be a hectic process considering that we all have our sleeping preferences. However, there are common traits we all look for in a mattress. For your convenience, we’ve done some research and have identified five crucial factors that need to be considered when shopping for a mattress.

Support and Comfort

A firm mattress shouldn’t only be comfortable but should also support the user’s body form factor. Your mattress should adapt to your spine without causing any unnecessary pressure on different points of your body. When lying flat on your bed, your mattress should provide proper alignment and support from your head to your toe, and especially your spine. If lying down on your current mattress causes you to toss and turn through the night restlessly, it is time to consider changing it. Common parts of our body lead to us tossing and turning include the hips, back, and shoulders since they tire quite quickly due to weight exerted on them. Memory foam mattresses, for instance, are comfortable and offer good support; two reasons why a lot of people prefer them. If you are looking for support and comfort, then a memory foam mattress might be your answer.

Mattress Density (Stiffness or Softness)

Go for a soft mattress that does not hamper blood flow or pinch your nerves due to compression. Stiff mattresses can be quite uncomfortable; which is why it is advisable that you try different mattresses before settling for one. Mattresses that are too soft cannot hold body weight, which causes the improper alignment of your spine. That is why it’s advisable that you go for a mattress that is neither too stiff nor too soft for your liking. It is worth noting that mattresses are available in three levels of density – low density, medium density, and high density. Choose a mattress that provides you the most natural feel when lying down.

Temperature Neutrality

This is one of the most important features to consider when out shopping for a mattress. A majority of low-quality foam mattresses tend to suffer a lot, especially when it comes to temperature neutrality and breathability. They often suffer from something known as the ‘oven’ effect, and that is why most low-end mattresses are unbearably hot at night. The reason why is because the material used to make the foam absorbs and retains your body heat, which makes it uncomfortable to sleep on the mattress after a while. The interesting thing is that some mattresses are the exact opposite of this. Such mattresses are awfully cold and take longer to get comfortable or warm. While they aren’t that common, you still need to avoid such as well. The good thing though is that advances in technology are helping produce improved mattresses – the two most common being foam and spring mattresses. Manufacturers who make such mattresses use special elements and materials that make them comfortable to sleep on through the night while retaining a comfortable temperature/warmth. However, you might need to look into several manufacturers and brands to find an option that suits your needs, taste, and preferences. Customer testimonials and reviews can be of great help.

Durability

Durable and quality mattresses do not come cheap. A mattress is a significant investment that will require you to take time to consider your options and to spend wisely. With that being said, it’s essential that the mattress that you choose is one that will last for years without any issues. It is worth keeping in mind that some mattresses might feel great initially only for their quality to start failing as days go by due to body imprint and sagging. This could spell doom to your sleeping patterns as it often increases pressure points and leads to spine misalignment. To be on the safe side, make sure that the mattress you invest in is a well-known brand created by a renowned manufacturer and has a strong base. The materials that have been used to build your mattress matter a lot too. Consider buying from a brand that provides its mattresses with 10-year warranty and remember to check the brand’s return policy before making any orders.

Warranty, Trial Period and Return Policy

Before spending your money on any mattress, one of your main considerations is whether your supplier provides enough warranty just in case the mattress gets damaged due to manufacturing faults. If a mattress doesn’t give enough warranty, then consider finding another option. Similarly, if your supplier doesn’t allow you to try the mattress for some time and is not willing to fully refund you if it’s uncomfortable, then move on. Today, internet mattress companies are offering a trial period of about 100-nights. There are some that even give their customers 365-nights to try the mattress. It is essential that you also take the time to find out if you’ll get a full refund when returning your mattress.

Five Mattresses To Steer Clear From

We’ve looked at five of the worst mattresses that one could buy – they are listed below. There are other types of mattresses, but the ones listed here are the main ones to look out for.

Promotional Mattresses

Promotional mattresses are often sold at reduced prices and are not of the same quality as their counterparts. While the pricing is often very attractive, remember that the retailers are placing them on the floor to attract people. They want unsuspecting customers to see the ridiculously low prices and walk in through the door. Furthermore, promotional mattresses usually don’t come with warranties and typically cannot be returned. If you’re tempted to get one of these mattresses, make sure that you ask all the right questions so that you know your options if you end up not liking the purchase. Promotional mattresses might be a great choice if you’re buying something for the guest bedroom that will not see that much traffic. But if you know the bed you are purchasing the mattress for is used often, then consider spending a little more money to get a quality product, and you won’t regret your decision.

Innerspring Mattresses Without Pocketed Coils

Is your partner often restless at night? If that is the case, then consider going for a mattress with motion isolation. With such a mattress, you will not be disturbed when someone else flips from side to side or gets up and down. Mattresses with innerspring aren’t your best choice. Products that do not have individually pocketed coils tend to have motion isolation-related problems. If you don’t sleep very well, and your partner tosses and turns or moves around a lot at night, then consider searching for a mattress that has motion isolation.

Thin Mattresses

A thin mattress usually is very uncomfortable sleeping on. This is especially true if you tend to sleep on your side or if you’re a bit heavy set. Go for a thick mattress as thicker ones provide more support and more cushioning. They also offer the padding some people require when sleeping. If you weigh well over 250 pounds, it’s advisable that you go for a mattress that’s more than ten inches thick. If you weight over 300 pounds, consider going for a product that’s around 14-inches thick.

Soft Mattresses

A lot of people do not know what they’re looking for when shopping for a mattress. There are tons of options out there, and without the right information, you might end up buying something that will do you more harm (both physical and financial) than good. A lot of people end up being dissatisfied with the mattress they purchased because they choose one that was either too firm or too soft. When visiting your local store to look shop for a mattress, ensure that you test several options before making a decision. Doing so will expose you to the different options available, allowing you to have a rough idea of what will work for you. A lot of people prefer medium-firm mattresses. However, remember that different brands will offer different qualities. It is, therefore, essential that you lay on the mattresses instead of relying on their description. If, by chance, you come across a mattress’ ILD number, take note of it. This number can be beneficial since the higher it is, the firmer a mattress is and the lower it is, the softer the mattress.

No Return Policy

If the mattress you are considering has a return policy, then you can rest assured that you will not be stuck with it if you find out that you do not like it. However, if your retailer tells you that you cannot return or exchange the mattress once you’ve bought it, then be very cautious. Mattresses are very expensive, that is why it’s essential that you invest in a product that will allow you to achieve better, higher quality sleep. If the mattress you are considering buying is one you can return if there’s a problem, then go ahead and buy it. This is especially important if you’re purchasing it over the internet. Because you cannot test the mattress before buying it, you can never know what you’re getting. Look for a product that comes with a 30-day return policy – thirty days is enough time for you to tell if you like the mattress or not.

The Best Mattress

Best for a Luxury Feel

Best Cooling Mattress

Best Budget Mattress

How We Found the Best Mattress

65Mattresses Evaluated

10Brands Tested

The Best Mattress

The whole ethos of the bed-in-the-box industry is that a universally great mattress exists. And that you can get it into your bedroom with less effort and for less money than traditionally thought. After interviewing sleep experts, researching materials, and testing 10 of the top mattresses, we agree.

Our top picks — Loom & Leaf, Novosbed, and GhostBed — rose to the top of the stack thanks to their supportive, high-end construction and snuggly sensation. If we’re being honest, though, we’d be excited to crawl into any of these beds after a long day. The right choice comes down to what kind of sleeper you are, how soft you like your bed, and how much you’re ready to invest in a great night’s sleep. If you already know where you fall on that scale, feel free to jump straight to our detailed reviews of all 10 mattresses we tested. Otherwise, read on.

Analysis paralysis? Subscribe to our newsletter.

Nice! Thanks for subscribing. Check your email to confirm.

The 3 Best Mattresses

The Best Mattresses: Summed Up

Loom & LeafNovosbedGhostbed
The BestFor a Luxury FeelCooling MattressBudget Mattress
PriceQueens starting at $1,299Queens starting at $999Queens starting at $795
Trial Period120 days120 days101 days
Mattress TypeMemory foamMemory foamMemory foam
StylePillow-topAerated top layerN/A
FirmnessMediumSoftestFirmest

Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress

Luxurious pillow-top
Excellent full-body support
Sturdy build
“White-glove” delivery

Pricier than competitors

Return to top

Why we chose it

Luxurious pillow-top

Oftentimes people equate supreme sleeping comfort with an upscale hotel bed, and that means one thing: pillow-top. Loom & Leaf is unique amongst new-wave memory foam models for preserving this design standard. It doesn’t skimp on the extra layer of quilted foam, either, sewing in generous tufts to create a truly plush surface. Testers found it a much more dimensional and supportive bed as a result.

Excellent full-body support

While other memory foam beds might accept your weight, sinking in wherever you apply the most pressure, Loom & Leaf seems to expand against you. It fills in the curves of the spine, the hollow of the knee, and even the back of the neck if you try it out sans pillow like we did. It’s also free from that uncomfortable “hammock effect,” where the mattress dips and pulls you in at the center. Our testers felt evenly supported everywhere.

Sturdy build

The Loom & Leaf also has the sturdiest edges of all the mattresses we tested: zero sag, even when putting your full body weight on the very edge. This tautness means that you can move around on the bed with greater ease and get out without disturbing a sleeping partner. It also means that if you like to curl up near the edge, you won’t be in danger of sliding off.

“White-glove” delivery

Most testers agreed that Loom & Leaf is in the upper echelon of comfort and support. And if you’re going for a full-scale luxury experience, get this: The company even offers “white-glove” delivery. Movers will bring your new mattress right into your bedroom and take the old one out for free. Our other top picks leave the heavy lifting up to you.

Points to consider

Pricier than competitors

Loom & Leaf was the uncontested favorite among our team, but that luxury comes at a price. Most of Loom & Leaf’s beds run at least $100 more than their closest competitors. Before making the leap, make sure you take a good look at our other top picks; the GhostBed offers similar support for $300 less. When you are ready to buy, rest easy knowing that every Loom & Leaf bed comes with a 120-day trial period — and a full refund if you’re not satisfied.

The Novosbed Medium

Cooling top layer
Uniquely responsive support
Customizable feel

Too squishy for some
Unsupportive edges

Return to top

Why we chose it

Cooling top layer

Novosbed’s standout feature is its top layer: two inches of aerated foam, with holes punched through the surface to increase sink and airflow. This perforated top creates an active cooling sensation — particularly great if you’re a sweaty sleeper. While Loom & Leaf also boasts a “cooling gel panel” to prevent overheating, our testers agreed that Novosbed’s aerated foam does the best job regulating body temperature.

Uniquely responsive support

The perforated top layer on Novosbed also creates a singular sensation when you lie down. After climbing into bed, you sink quickly and deeply, as though the mattress is enveloping you. But then you hit its support layers. Thanks to this nesting-then-holding process, Novosbed is fully supportive while still being the softest and squishiest of our top picks. One tester — who utilizes a collection of pillows and wedges to find her perfect support — reported, “I don’t think I even need a pillow.”

Customizable feel

Not sure where you lie on the squishiness scale? Novosbed solves this with its Comfort+ package — a layer of either firming or softening foam that can be zipped right into your mattress’ housing. If you’re having trouble sleeping at any point during the 120-day Novosbed trial, the company will send you a Comfort+ layer free of charge. Our other top picks do offer generous return policies if you’re unsatisfied, but we appreciate that Novosbed has a way to tweak the experience without the hassle of buying a whole new mattress.

Points to consider

Too squishy for some

If you don’t like the feeling of being cradled by your mattress, then Novosbed isn’t the choice for you. While many testers loved its cozy, sinking-yet-supported feel, others weren’t as thrilled. Some even described the initial settling process as being “enveloped in quicksand” or “sucked into another dimension.” Those who prefer to lieon topof their mattress rather thaninit will prefer GhostBed — the firmest of our top picks — or Loom & Leaf, whose pillow-top strikes a very happy medium between springy and squishy.

Unsupportive edges

Novosbed’s silky top also comes with one downfall: Its edges are exceptionally soft. If you like to curl up near the side of the bed, you will slowly slip off. Edge sleepers will fare better with the Loom & Leaf or GhostBed mattress — both of which are uniformly taut across their surfaces.

GhostBed Mattress

More affordable than competitors
Comfortable, even support

Too firm for some
No-frills design

Return to top

Why we chose it

More affordable than competitors

Don’t let this turn you off: GhostBed’s lower price tag is not in any way a mark of lower quality. In fact, our testers almost universally praised this mattress for its even support and slow sink. For $300 less than Loom & Leaf, the GhostBed provides a similarly taut and springy feel — although it lacks the luscious pillow-top that took our favorite bed to the top of the charts.

Comfortable, even support

Like the Loom & Leaf, GhostBed has a robust and even surface from edge to edge. It’s the firmest option among our top picks; this helped us relax from head to toe, since we weren’t just sinking in at our heaviest point. Testers also loved that they could move across and off of the bed with ease, and that they could sit on its sturdy edges without plopping to the floor. This strength is tempered with enough give that the mattress fills spine curves whether you’re a back or side sleeper. One tester affirmed, “Just the right mix of soft and supportive. I would buy this.”

Exceptionally durable

GhostBed outperformed our other top picks in Consumer Reports’ durability testing, earning an “excellent” rating, while Loom & Leaf and Novosbed both took home “very good.” The test pummels mattresses with weights to simulate eight years of sleep, ensuring that your big investment will hold up over time. We were impressed that GhostBed — our most affordable mattress — is also likely to be the most long-lasting.

Points to consider

Too firm for some

GhostBed fell near the “firmest” end on our squish-scale. It has a bit less yield than either the Loom & Leaf (with its forgiving pillow-top) or the Novosbed (with its sinkable top layer). Our testers still approved of it pretty unanimously, maintaining that GhostBed’s firmness lent extra support and stability. Still, if you prefer a more deluxe feel, you may be better off with one of our other top picks.

No-frills design

As the most affordable mattress on our list, GhostBed lacks some of the luxury features that we loved from our other top picks. For instance, while GhostBed offers comparable support to the Loom & Leaf, it’s missing the plush pillow-top that gave Loom & Leaf its upscale, hotel feel. Hot sleepers will miss Novosbed’s layer of perforated foam, which allows for better airflow and dissipates heat throughout the night. In short: GhostBed is reliably comfortable and well worth its price tag. Just don’t expect anything fancy.

How We Chose the Best Mattress

Painless shopping, easy delivery

We started by tracking down the most promising contenders — 65 popular mattresses from the 29 best-known online brands. Why did we look online and not in-store? Put simply, the value is greater. Prices, purchasing, and shipping are straightforward and simple. Customer service also tends to be more convenient and responsive, with handy channels like web chat.

Besides the simplicity of having your bed delivered right to your door, online brands offer generous trial and return policies. This allows you to test out a bed the only way you really can: by sleeping on it night after night. The trial period is a better good-sleep-guarantee than briefly lying down on a mattress in-store.

All-foam, multi-layer construction

According to our mattress gurus, there are two key components to a comfortable night’s sleep. First: Your bed should be memory foam. “Memory foam has advantages,” Nick Robinson of Sleep Like the Dead told us. “Above average comfort. Conforms to body. Absorbs motion so it’s couple-friendly.” When surveyed, owners of memory foam beds rank their satisfaction higher than owners of any other bed type. We made this our first criteria.

The second thing we looked for was multi-layer construction. This allows for multiple points of interaction, as the layers support, respond to, and pull away from one another — rather than a single layer, which creates a direct relationship between your body weight and the foam. The result? A perfect sinkage-to-support ratio.

As an additional precaution, we also made sure that our top picks were approved by Certipur, a national organization that tests home furnishing foams for safe, high-quality materials. You can learn more about Certipur standards in our FAQ section.

Medium-firm feel

As for softness, we narrowed in on medium-firm beds. Hear us out: Mattress feel is definitely personal, but we learned that most people actually have a pretty similar comfort window. The ticket is medium-firm support. JB Duke Hotel manager Gregg Hilker describes it as “the most neutral — not too hard, not too soft, but [with] a high-quality feel to it.”

Medium-firm is also key for durability, longevity, and a cooler night’s sleep (the less you sink into the mattress, the less your body heat forms a cocoon). Need proof? A 2007 sleep study had participants swap out their existing mattress for a generic medium-firm version, and all experienced better sleep and significant pain relief.

Tester-approved for full-body comfort

We combed through our initial list of 65 mattresses and found the ones that met all these expectations. From there, we selected the 10 most interesting, well-designed, and talked-about models to test out in our office.

After a week of practice naps — “no, really, we’re working” — we can tell you that all of these mattresses live up to their hype. Each one was truly comfortable and yawn-inducing: beds we’d be excited to climb into every night. In the end, our top picks were the models that were consistently pegged as testers’ favorites, garner excellent longevity ratings from Consumer Reports, and boast high-caliber construction that aligns with their asking price.

Testing also helped us develop a scale of firmness and identify where each mattress fell — so if you’re not sure about your squish-tolerance, you can sleep vicariously through our testers. Check out ratings and sensory descriptions for all 10 in our buying guide.

Guide to Mattresses

How to find the right mattress for you

Ultimately, the best mattress for you comes down to your own preferences regarding feel. If you know roughly where you fall on the soft/firm spectrum, you may fall in love with one of the other mattresses we tested. Below are our testers’ observations to help get you started.

Yogabed Luxury Memory Foam Mattress :Best for anyone who loves an ultra-soft, ultra-sinkable bed

  • The foam:Thick, airy, and incredibly soft
  • The feel:So plush, it’s like you tucked yourselfinsidethe foam
  • From our testers:A tendency to feel “stuck” inside your body impression; “When I sleep on a mattress this soft, I feel achy when I wake up”
  • Avoid if:You don’t enjoy the sensation of being cocooned within your mattress

Nest Bedding Love & Sleep Mattress :Best for side-sleepers and lightweight individuals who won’t impact a firmer bed

  • The foam:Heavier and jelly-like, with lots of sink
  • The feel:Like falling into warm, shifting sand
  • From our testers:“It feels okay when you’re lying down flat, but when you apply any direct pressure — like propping yourself up on an elbow — you sink in weirdly deep”
  • Avoid if:You’re a back sleeper, a larger individual, or generally don’t like a super-squishy bed

Casper Sleep Mattress :Best for cozy sleepers who want a mellow level of support

  • The foam:Medium-soft and reactive, with a fair amount of sink
  • The feel:Soft and cozy with gentle push-back, but not incredibly supportive
  • From our testers:“It makes me yawn just lying on it” — although many preferred a firmer mattress with a little more support
  • Avoid if:You tend to prefer a firmer, denser mattress

The Purple Bed :Best for relieving common pressure points in sore sleepers

  • The foam: Viscous, undulating gel foam
  • The feel: Like a new-age water bed; dips and billows with your every move
  • From our testers: From “jelly trampoline,” to “tapioca,” to “terrible garbage,” this was our most polarizing bed
  • Avoid if: You sleep with a partner (movement carries easily) or if the feel of a water bed is off-putting to you

The Novosbed Medium :Best for anyone who runs hot and needs the extra airflow while sleeping

  • The foam:Soft and supple, with a perforated surface to keep you cool
  • The feel:“Nesting-then-holding”; sink followed by active support
  • From our testers:It’s so reactive, “I don’t think I even need a pillow”
  • Avoid if:You suffer from back pain and need a more reactive surface

Saatva Loom & Leaf Mattress :Best for most people; a true “medium-firm” mattress that will support most sleepers

  • The foam:Multilayer memory foam cushioned with a plush, quilted pillow-top
  • The feel:Incredibly dimensional and reactive; a great sink-to-support ratio
  • From our testers:“Everything else was an adequate experience. This is actively great”
  • Avoid if:You prefer a mattress on either the softer or the firmer end — this one falls right in the middle

Bear Mattress :Best for individuals with back pain who need a little more support

  • The foam:On the firmer side, less sinkable and reactive than others
  • The feel:Pushes back as you lie down, creating the right balance between cozy softness and bone-aligning lift
  • From our testers:“It has a lot of support, which I like; I feel held”
  • Avoid if:You like a bouncier, squishier mattress — this one’s a little less playful

GhostBed Mattress :Best for anyone who doesn’t mind sacrificing a few frills for a better price tag

  • The foam:Firm, but with enough give to fit your body’s contours
  • The feel:An even tautness that supports the body from head to toe
  • From our testers:“Just the right mix of soft and supportive. I would buy this”
  • Avoid if:You’re looking for a more specialized mattress (e.g. pillow-top or cooling features)

Leesa Mattress :Best for anyone who needs a firm, supportive bed but craves a little extra squish

  • The foam:Dense resistance with a super slow sink
  • The feel:Firm at first, but with a gradual give that left some testers feeling unsupported
  • From our testers:Many agreed, it was “Firmer than I’d like”
  • Avoid if:You like a mattress with a little more springiness to it

Tuft & Needle Mattress :Best for sleepers who need an unrelentingly supportive bed for better alignment

  • The foam:Two layers: a thick, sturdy foundation and a thin “pressure relief” layer
  • The feel:A firm, confident surface that has little to no give
  • From our testers:Most found it non-dimensional; “It’s a slab of foam and you lie on top of it”
  • Avoid if:You prefer a mattress that forms to your contours for better pressure relief

Mattress FAQs

If you’re tossing and turning and waking up tired, your mattress is probably too old and no longer suits your body’s mechanics (if it ever did). The Better Sleep Council recommends swapping your bed out every five to seven years. Longer than that, and you’re likely lying on lifeless springs and deflated cushion.

Besides the convenience of shopping from home and having a bed delivered to your door — or even straight to your bedroom — online mattress brands offer unparallelled transparency and, generally, fairer pricing than retail stores. Referred to as “Big Mattress” by entrepreneurs, these retailers are known for misleading marketing (e.g. selling the same bed with a new name). They also have a reputation for hefty markups, often selling mattresses for 30 to 50 percent above wholesale prices.

Bed-in-a-box companies build their business models off of opposing tactics, with direct-to-consumer pricing and a simple product lineup. Since you’re cutting out the middleman, purchasing a mattress from one of our picks can help you save money. And thanks to generous trial periods and free return policies, buying a mattress online is no riskier than buying one in-store.

If you’re purchasing for your child, a Twin or Twin XL may be appropriate if the size of the room is a constraint. If you have the space for it, then a Full (a.k.a., Double) may be better to see them through growth spurts.

For most adults, a Queen bed is generous enough at five feet wide and 6.5 feet long. Kings add another 16 inches in width. The super luxurious California King loses, surprisingly, four inches of a King’s width but tacks it back on in length.

Bed Measurements:

  • Twin: 39” x 75”
  • Twin Extra Long: 39” x 80”
  • Full: 54” x 75”
  • Full Extra Long: 54” x 80”
  • Queen: 60” x 80”
  • King: 76” x 80”
  • California King: 72” x 84”

The loft (or thickness) of your pillow should play well with the firmness of your mattress, body metrics, and preferred sleeping position. The more you sink into your mattress, the thinner your pillow should be. If you’re lightweight, choose an extra-firm mattress, or sleep on your side, your head will be farther from the surface — so you need a thicker pillow to bridge the gap. For specific recommendations, check out our review of the best pillows.

We only considered mattresses approved by Certipur, a national third-party organization that tests the quality and safety of furniture foams. To receive the Certipur label, manufacturers have to submit their product to two initial rounds of testing and then annual random testings. Certipur foam is free of ozone depletors, toxic flame retardants, and plasticizers. As a result, it exhibits low VOC — volatile organic compounds. (These break down and release the fumes infamously known as “new mattress stink.”)

You’ve probably encountered the wisdom that you should flip over your bed every six months so it wears evenly. But since memory foam is stacked in an intentional order, you’ll want to keep the proper comfort layers on top. Instead of flipping it upside-down, rotate your memory foam bed from head-to-foot to distribute wear and tear.

Most modern beds don’t need a box spring, however many mattress warranties require it if you want your bed’s warranty to remain valid. A box-spring is a supportive, foundational block that holds up your mattress so that your mattress stays on a dependably flat area. It is beneficial to use a box-spring to limit wear and tear on your mattress and to provide extra support, however, a box spring is unneeded when it comes to memory foam mattresses — anything that will hold them off the ground will do just fine.

The average mattress performs best for 8 years, however, there are a variety of factors that affect the lifespan of your bed. Do your best to keep your mattress dry and clean. Try to bar anyone from jumping or standing on your mattress. Remember to rotate your mattress (don’t flip it over!) once a month to minimize body impressions that will leave a lasting effect. Make sure to use a proper supportive bed-frame or box spring, and never bend your mattress.

Lifespans of different types of mattresses:

  • Latex foam: 12 years
  • Memory Foam: 10 years
  • Hybrid: 10 years
  • Innerspring: 8 years
  • Pillowtop: 7 years

Usually, manufacturers introduce new models in late spring or summer and will discount older mattress models once newer models roll in. Memorial Day and Labor Day (and other three-day weekend/holidays) have a history of offering big sales and discounts to consumers, as do holidays like Black Friday or Christmas. Outside of those times, though, mattress prices mostly stay the same throughout the year.

More Reviews for a Good Night’s Sleep

Your mattress is the most critical part of a good night’s sleep — but it’s not the only thing that’ll help your REM cycle. Check out some of our other home goods reviews below. From a smart thermostat that adjusts your climate at bedtime to a pillow with perfect neck-to-shoulder alignment, we found what you need to feel rested and refreshed night after night.

10 Crib Mattresses to Help Your Baby Sleep Safe and Soundly

Here’s hopingeveryonewill snooze through the night.

Newborns spend most of their time sleeping, so the crib mattress is one of the most important purchases you’ll make as a new mom or dad (no pressure, right?). First and foremost, it needs to be supportive and made with safe materials. On top of that, it should be easy to clean for inevitable accidents and have dual firmness if you want to continue using it when your baby becomes a toddler.

The Good Housekeeping Institute scientists, engineers, and parenting experts review baby gear of all kinds, with a big emphasis on sleep-related products like cribs, swaddle blankets, sleep sacks and more. We’ve picked the top crib mattresses ahead that offer something for everyone, no matter what your preferences are for your baby’s crib. But first, here’s what to consider as you shop for a crib mattress:

What is the best type of mattress for a baby?

The best mattress for a newborn is one that’s extra firm; in fact, it should be so hard that as an adult, you can’t imagine it possibly being comfortable to sleep on. When the baby is about a year old, they can have a slightly softer (yet still firm) surface to sleep on. Many crib mattresses are reversible with infant and toddler sides so you can use them same one for several years.

Just like the inner materials in an adult mattress, for crib mattresses, you’ll commonly choose between an innerspring or foam.Innerspring mattresseshave steel coils to make it sturdy (the more coils, the more supportive it’ll be), whilefoam mattressesare usually made of dense yet lightweight polyurethane foam. Foam mattresses safe for your child to sleep on as long as they’re firm enough. Lastly, to make certain that you’re not exposing baby to harmful levels of off-gassing VOCs, check that the mattress is GreenGuard gold certified, which means the product has been reviewed to ensure low emissions.

How tight should a crib mattress fit?

There should be no gaps between the mattress and the crib sides. If you can fit more than two fingers between the sides of the crib and the mattress, it’s too small and therefore poses a risk to your child. The crib sheets also need to fit securely enough that your baby can’t pull the edges up. An infant’s crib should have nothing else in it: no pillows, blankets, stuffed animals, or other toys. There also shouldn’t be anything hanging over the crib that baby can pull down.

One more safety tip to keep in mind: when it comes to crib mattresses, it’s best to buy new instead of used. A used one may not be as firm, can have mildew or bacteria growth, and may not be up-to-date with the latest safety regulations.

Here are the best crib mattresses you can buy for your baby:

The 12 Best Mattresses for 2020

Transparency Disclosure– We may receive a referral fee (at no additional cost to the buyer) for products purchased through the links on our site or other applicable pages. To learn more, please read our full disclosure pagehere . We also encourage you to read about how we may research and/or test Products here .

April 2020 Update:

The Sleep Advisor team is excited to announce ourupdated mattress picks for 2020!

What makes a high-quality new mattress stand out from the rest? Is it the material, construction, comfort, rating, or just the price point?

A lot of people ask the question,“What is the best mattress you can buy?”The truth is the answer depends on many different factors! Teenagers will have different needs than adults and seniors, and stomach sleepers tend to have completely different preferences than, let’s say, side sleepers.

With that in mind, we came up with thea roundup of top rated mattress brands for 2020. We broke it down into categories by type, sleeper position, age, medical conditions, and specific needs.

It won’t take more than10 minutesof your time. You can use thequick links to the rightto navigate around the page easily. Hopefully it’ll give you an idea of what you’re shopping for and make things a bit easier.

Ready? Let’s dig in.

The 12 Best Rated Mattresses(Updated – April 2020)

  • Type: Memory Foam
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Memory Foam
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Memory Foam
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: All Foam
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: All Foam
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Hybrid
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
  • Type: Gel Memory Foam

Nectar – Exceptional Value

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • OEKO-TEX® Certified
  • 365-Day Trial
  • Forever Warranty

Forget everything you think you know about memory foam left over from the 1970s because modern memory foam has a lot to offer folks looking for pressure relief without overheating. Nectar’s deep hug and sleek design has gotten a lot of attention since its 2017 launch. These features and more have made quite a splash in the bed-in-a-box space.

Why are we impressed?Regardless of budget, a bed is an investment, so you want to be sure you’re getting a lot of great bed for the price. Not only does Nectar offer a lot of quality features (a cooling Tencel and more), furniture company Resident also works to keep the price affordable by selling online.

Adding to the value is their industry-leading sleep trial, which allows you to keep the bed for a year until you’re certain it’s the right mattress for you, and this is matched by its Forever warranty that lasts for as long as you own the product. If you’ve been nervous about memory foam or whether you could possibly order a bed online, Nectar has taken nearly all the risk out of this important purchase.

Want to learn more?Check out our full review here.

The WinkBed – Luxury Feel

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • “Any Reason” Guarantee
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Made in the USA

WinkBeds are built in Wisconsin by a company committed to handcrafting every mattress to be comfortable and ultra-supportive. Unlike hybrid mattresses you may have seen before, this choice blends foams with two separate supportive coil systems: one to tailor to your shape, and the other to provide high-profile support.

What to love here?The company has built these beds to last, and it shows in the premium craftsmanship. The pressure-relieving Eurotop cradles the body above a 3-step support system beneath that is separated into zones meant to hold your body in a neutral position.

This company stands by their brands, and if you decide to go with this bed, your purchase is covered by a lifetime warranty and an “any-reason guarantee.” If your needs happen to change over the course of the mattresses’ lifetime, you can get a different feel (firmer? Softer?) for half the retail price.

If that wasn’t luxury enough for you, you can also elect to buy an optional foundation that has an airconditioning unit incorporated into the design so you can specify the temperature of your bed for your own best sleep.

Brooklyn Aurora – Amazing Cooling

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty
  • Made in the USA

Brooklyn Bedding is based in Phoenix, Arizona so they know a thing or two about heat, and they’ve put their knowledge to the test in their line of mattresses. Their luxury model, the Aurora, pulls out all the stops to deliver a comfortable and supportive bed that shouldn’t wake you in a pool of sweat.

What stands out?This cool sleep experience starts with TitanCool™, which is a proprietary material infused into the cover that is designed to keep the temperature at a steady 88 degrees, ideal for sleep. This is followed by a series of foams that incorporate copper and gel to whisk excess heat away from the body and disperse it throughout the mattress, where it can easily escape through the pocketed coils.

If you have specific firmness requirements, this model can cater to them with a Soft, Medium, and Firm model, depending on your preference. We’d recommend the Soft or Medium for side sleepers and perhaps the Firm for stomach sleepers, though you can keep the bed for 120 days to make sure it’s the best fit for you.

Casper – All Sleeping Positions

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 100-Night Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty
  • Designed and Assembled in the USA

Maybe your partner and you have wildly different sleep preferences and body types or maybe you’re a combo sleeper who likes to move from side to back to stomach all night long. If this sounds like you, Casper’s famous “universal feel” might be your ticket to sleep heaven.

What’s its best feature?The foams inside Casper have been strategically designed and ordered to provide a graduated feel, meaning a wide variety of body shapes and weights should achieve the right ratio of comfort and support without bottoming out. Versatility adds a lot of value to a mattress, and this was increased with the addition of zoned support in the transitional foam layer that helps stomach sleepers, in particular, maintain good spine alignment.

Casper’s all-foam design also has a great deal to offer for those who prefer good motion isolation so their partner’s movements aren’t keeping them up at night. If you prefer a bit more bounce, you could check out the hybrid version as well.

DreamCloud – Pressure Relief

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 365-Day Trial
  • Lifetime Warranty

DreamCloud is Resident’s luxury model, and it definitely cuts an impressively high silhouette at 15 inches. If you don’t believe that that much bed could possibly come packed into a box, this company aims to prove you wrong with 6 layers that mix premium foam with memory materials and individually wrapped coils.

What do we love about it?In 2019, the company introduced a new version of DreamCloud that made the bed just a touch softer to offer a deeper cradle for those looking for great pressure relief. Side sleepers, in particular, may prefer this newer version to the previous model for this reason.

While traditional memory beds might trap heat, DreamCloud was designed to be breathable, without sacrificing body conformance or that classic deep hug feeling. Air can flow freely through the pocketed coils to keep hotter air circulating out and cooler air circulating in. The foams minimize motion transfer, while the coils supply bounce and tailored support.

If you’re unsure, the company gives you 365 days to try it at home and backs your purchase with a lifetime warranty, giving you value for a fraction of the retail price in stores.

Layla – Memory Foam

  • Double-sided Firmness
  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • Lifetime Warranty
  • Made in the USA

If it’s a choice you want, maybe you should look into the flippable mattress from Layla, which offers two different firmnesses depending on what side of the bed is facing up. The entire construction is encased in a cooling cover that further modernizes a classic memory feel.

Why are we impressed?Layla is proof that there’s no one way to do memory foam, and they emphasize the fact by packing two different experiences into one construction. You can try out both the deeper classic sink of the Soft and the gentler cradle of the Firm to see what suits you best, and if you like both, you can flip it whenever you want.

This brand further keeps things cool by putting copper into their foams. This naturally antimicrobial substance is excellent at conducting heat, which means the heat of your body shouldn’t congregate in the foams around your shape but travel away and out the air channels.

The design of the third layer provides zoned support so that extra reinforcement around the middle of the bed can help keep the hips elevated and the spine in a neutral position.

Nolah – Side Sleepers

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • 15-Year Warranty
  • Wildlife Initiative
  • Made in the USA

Do you love penguins? Worried about the fate of the Great White Shark? What if you could help give back to wildlife conservation and buy a bed at the same time? Each year, the company donates 7% of its profits back to wildlife protection, and you get the choose the animal you’d most like to protect.

Okay, now let’s talk about the bed. With 20 years of combined experience, the founders of Nolah wanted to change the memory foam and latex industry with a new feel. That led them to create the proprietary Nolah Air Foam that helps reduce pressure in the hip, shoulder, and back regions.

What makes it special?The company positions its bed as having four times less peak pressure than comparable memory foam products. If you’re a frustrated side sleeper that suffers from excessive pressure, then this product holds major appeal.

This ten-inch mattress starts with Nolah AirFoam that should be great for side sleepers. The second layer is a 1-inch transitional foam that behaves much like latex. The base layer is 7-inches thick and comprised of high-density polyurethane designed for steady support.

Big Fig – Heavy People

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • 20-Year Warranty
  • Made in the USA

In the past, plus-sized people have had to be wary about their mattress choices, reading the fine print of warranties and worrying if their size will cause premature sagging. With brands like Big Fig and their hybrid, their worries can be put to rest, literally!

This mattress was built with a mix of high-density foam and high-profile individually wrapped coils. The foam and coils tailor to your shape to provide exceptional spine alignment, even for folks with larger frames. The mattress comes with a foundation, which is built to provide a sturdier support system than traditional box springs.

What’s its best feature?This company, which is exclusively based in Cleveland, Ohio, stands by its construction, which has been tested using a 350-pound weight to simulate 20 years of use. This testing was 100% objective and performed by a third-party organization.

If you’re worried about sleeping hot, Big Fig has you covered. The perforated foams were treated with gel to reduce heat retention. The edges of the bed were built with 80 ILD foam to ensure edge-to-edge support, more usable space, and ample support even when sitting on the side.

Casper Wave – Spine Alignment

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 100-Day Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty
  • Designed and Assembled in the USA

If you’re surfing the web because your old mattress is hurting your back, you’ll want to look at a choice that excels in spinal alignment. The Wave, made by internet-famous Casper, should be a great choice for those looking to improve their sleep posture.

What makes it special?This 13-inch mattress has five layers of foam strategically designed to cradle different body shapes evenly regardless of their position. They achieve this with targeted support from gel pods, positioned in the portions of the bed requiring extra support while maintaining softness in other areas so that you don’t build up pressure.

The result? The Wave was made to align your spine and provide comfort and support. We think the soft mix will work exceptionally well for side sleepers, hoping to keep their hips elevated while still letting their legs and shoulders sink in for a comfortable cradle.

The breathable foams and cover should work to keep you cool in this beautiful all-white design. Take their ergonomic design for a spin and see if it does the trick for you.

Helix – Customizable

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 100-Day Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty
  • Made in the USA

We know you. Compromise just won’t do, and the perfect bed is out there, but you just need to know what to look for, right?

The Helix brand is not only focused on advanced customization, but also on helping you decide exactly what you need to sleep better and feel great. There’s a short quiz to take (along with your partner if you co-sleep) and out will pop the color and name of a bed Helix thinks will work perfectly for you.

What stands out?Those in the market for choice in their beds can browse the 16 choices on offer from Helix. These include Luxe models that add a little extra flourish, as well as a model designed for plus-sized sleepers.

All Helix beds are hybrids, but that’s where the similarities end. Their proprietary foams were designed and layered to deliver different feels and different sinkages, and the company will work with you even after you’ve made your purchase to make sure you find the right choice.

Avocado – Organic Materials

  • GREENGUARD Gold Certified
  • Certified Organic Materials
  • Made Safe
  • 365-Day Trial
  • 25-Year Warranty
  • Made in the USA

With more and more attention shifting to climate change and the need for organic and sustainable products, the market is filled with all-natural options. We think Avocado is a great pick in this space, and it gives you a lot of options, including pillow-tops, EuroTops, and sizes.

What is its best feature?Avocado has gone to great lengths to secure multiple third-party certifications guaranteeing the safety of their materials for both you and the environment it’s sourced from. It is one of few mattress companies to have secured the Made Safe seal, which states that the product is free from toxic ingredients, and the factories which manufacture the bed have been certified by both GOLS and GOTS, which state that the materials are organic.

The bed is built from Dunlop latex that stands over tempered steel coils that are ergonomically zoned to provide the right mixture of support and comfort to the sleeper. This is all held together without chemical adhesives or flame retardants, opting for organic wool, instead. If you prefer a vegan option, there is another model that forgoes the use of wool.

Sojourn – Budget Choice

  • CertiPUR-US® Certified
  • 120-Day Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty
  • Made in the USA

We believe that a mattress doesn’t have to be incredibly expensive to be good. Sojourn (previously sold as Ultimate Dreams) is the product that aims to prove it. With 12” total and three layers, you get that typical memory foam “hug” and feel many of us are familiar with for a fraction of the price you’d see in retail stores and even among online brands.

What’s its best feature?Honestly, the price is hard to beat for a bed that uses this level of quality materials. Dreamfoam is committed to keeping prices down and manages to do it by manufacturing at their own factory in Phoenix.

If you’re looking to furnish a guest room or are just shopping on a tighter budget, we think Sojourn is a great choice that should be versatile enough to accommodate a variety of sleepers in whatever position they prefer. Treat yourself to the pressure relief of memory foam without the buyer’s remorse from spending more than you can afford.

Best Mattress by Material and Type

So what is the top mattress material and type ? The unvarnished truth is that there is no clear winner because mattress feels and styles are so subjective and depend so much on individual body types and needs. Depending on how you are shaped, different mattress characteristics may be more or less preferable, and your preferences will likely be different than those of even the person sleeping right next to you.

Knowing a little bit more about each type of mattress, however, can help you narrow down your selection, so you can make the best possible choice for you and your family.

Memory Foam

This is an incredibly popular type for the average sleeper. Because of this, some of our top picks are from this category. It typically has a familiar hug feel and it contours to your body, providing fantastic pain and pressure point relief.

However, the biggest upside can also create a big downside, and that’s sleeping hot. New and advanced constructions solved this problem with gel and open cell construction, allowing more air to pass through and less overall heat retention.

Memory Foam bed structure example (Top to bottom: Two layers of memory foam, support foam)

Pros:

  • Good Pressure Point Relief
  • Nice and Memorable Feel
  • Good Hug and Contouring
  • Motion Isolation

Considerations:

  • Can Sleep Hot (Mostly for traditional foam; gel and open cell solve this problem to a degree, but it’s less cool than latex and coil)

Innerspring (Coil)

Most people have slep on one of these traditional non-memory foam beds at some point. Compared to new and advanced materials, you would think that coil mattresses don’t have anything to bring to the table anymore.

However, these options still provide some of the best cooling, edge support, and durability. And most hybrids combine coils with other types of materials such as latex or foam.

Classic spring bed structure (Top to bottom: foam layer, felt pad, comfort coils, foam layer)

Pros:

Considerations:

  • May Not Conform That Well
  • No “Hug” Feel
  • Can Be Noisy

These beds are best for people who want traditional coil feel, good support, and sturdy edge support.

Latex

Latex became very popular in the last couple years due to exceptional cooling, comfort, and durability. On top of that, it’s one of the most “green” materials. There are two types used in the production of bedding systems:

  • Natural– This is harvested from Hevea-Brasilenis tree (eco-friendly but expensive) and comes in either Dunlop or Talalay form
  • Synthetic– Materials are produced by mixing natural tree sap and synthetic polymers (cheaper but less environment-friendly)

Latex bed structure example (Top to bottom: Latex foam, high density foam)

Pros:

  • Durable
  • Great Cooling
  • Good Bounce
  • Eco-Friendly

Considerations:

  • Expensive (especially natural) – however, those online tend to be a much better price.

If you sleep hot and are looking for a good and durable bed that’s also good for the environment, and if you can afford it, you very likely won’t be sorry if you go with latex.

Hybrid

Combining two or more material types in a single mattress creates a hybrid with what many view as a much better sleep experience. The thought is that you get all the pros with less or none of the cons, and typically there are brands that have built very high ratings off of this strategy.

Hybrid bed structure example (Top to bottom: pillow top, memory foam, individually wrapped comfort coils, support coils, memory foam and edge support foam layer)

The most popular combinations are:

True Hybrid

Coil + Memory or Latex Foam. Sleepers typically get fantastic durability, bounce, and cooling from innerspring and contouring and hug from foam. See the rest of our top picks here.

Pillow Top

Coil + Pillow Top should provide more comfort and relief for pressure points caused by the firmness of coil beds. If you’d like to learn more about pillow top beds be sure to read our full guide.

Foam Hybrids

These beds do not contain any springs and use a combination of different foam materials to enhance cooling or provide more comfort for the sleeper. An example would be manufacturing that combines synthetic latex up top and memory foam in the second layer.

Pros:

Considerations:

  • Usually Slightly More Expensive Than Normal Models

Organic

This is a subcategory considering organic materials can be used in many different types of construction. But, since many people are looking for organic and eco-friendly mattress options without chemicals, we wanted to include it on our list.

Back in the 1970s, the US law stated that all beds must contain flame retardants to prevent accidental cigarette caused fires. These days, there are way fewer smokers than back then, and people are looking for clean and chemical-free products.

Mattresses are graded as 0-100% organic, meaning that if it’s 0%, it’s not natural at all. The closer you get to 100%, the more you will likely have to pay. The more eco-friendly materials are plant-based memory foam, non-synthetic latex, and, to a degree, coil with an organic pillow top.

Pros:

  • Good for the Environment
  • Good for Your Health

Considerations:

  • Costs Considerably More

Example: Amerisleep (no emission production with inclusion of natural materials)

Advanced and Custom Foam

Since the invention of memory foam, manufacturers have experimented with other types of foams, especially those based on latex and polyurethane to battle the heat retention. Apart from different base materials, they also tested different shapes and changing the manufacturing process to improve airflow, durability, and bounce while keeping the hug and contouring. Here are the most common types of foam:

  • Polyurethane– Usually serves as a base for most mattresses
  • Convoluted Foam– Also known as “egg crate foam” can be used to improve air circulation
  • Latex Rubber– Environment friendly and durable

Examples:

Waterbeds

This an interesting and unconventional type. The main feature is that waterbeds use water instead of foam or coils to give it structure and provide comfort and pain relief. Water distributes your weight evenly, and relieves pressure points, which has the potential to be useful for arthritis or back pain.

Pros:

  • Pain Point and Pressure Relief
  • Distributes Weight Evenly
  • Can Be Cheaper than Foam or Coil Beds
  • Good for Allergies
  • Easy to Clean

Considerations:

  • Less Durable than Other Types
  • Needs to be Filled with Water
  • It’s Not for Everyone

We created a detailed guide about waveless water mattresses so make sure to check it out if you want to know more about this type and see the ratings.

Airbeds

Having guests over or going camping? Then this type is for you. Of course, it’s not for everyday use, and you can’t expect to have a perfect night sleep on it, but for these occasions, it’s better than the sofa. Airbeds, as the name suggests, use air to provide support.

Pros:

  • Portable and Easily Carried on a Trip
  • Easily Deployed (most of them come with an electric or hand pump)
  • Inexpensive

Considerations:

  • Not for Long-term Use
  • Cannot Replace a Proper Bed

One of Our Top Choices: SoundAsleep Dream Series

Want to see more?See the 10 Top Rated Inflatable Air Beds and why we chose them.

Bed in a Box

Convenient and typically far more affordable than brands that have to deal with the overhead that comes with storefronts, bed in a box – which are mattresses ordered online – are an excellent solution for your bedding needs. You can order them from the comfort of your own home and have your new bed mailed directly to your door. Because most come with extended trial periods and standard warranties, they are a low-risk buy.

In addition, most of the top brands make them to order, so they are not sitting in warehouses for an extended time. Boxed beds are a relatively newer concept in the mattress industry, making it easier and more affordable than ever to have a great night’s rest.

Read more:Top Boxed Picks

Bunk Beds

If you know the criteria to look for, choosing the right bunk bed for your home can be easy. However, there are a few different considerations than a mattress that fits in a standard frame or that sits directly on the floor.

Things to keep in mind during your search include thickness, size, and firmness. Many frames for this style require something thinner, so make sure to get something that will provide enough support without bottoming out. Some companies also offer a range of firmnesses to fit this style, which can correspond to the preferred sleeping position.

Just think about who is using the bunk bed and what the best fit for that person looks like. We hope to make the process easier with our list of top brands and ratings.

Futon

Buying a futon comes with many considerations, from budget to function. However, whether you are looking for an occasional sleeping space for guests or need to greatly maximize the functionality of in your personal room, there are a wealth of options out there to choose from.

Futons serve a dual purpose, meaning that it is important to purchase one that not only looks great, but something that accommodates sleeping and sitting positions. Choosing the right one can be the difference between feeling an uncomfortable frame underneath and spending the night in a deep, restful slumber.

Read more:

Comfortable Sleeper Sofa

A good sleeper sofa can make the most of your available space while hosting guests or having sleepovers. Having one piece of furniture that acts as two can help save space and add more overall value to your furniture set. There are a variety of styles out there, including many that simply fold down and others that pull out of a sturdy base.

It is imperative to pick a brand that is comfortable while functioning as a couch and a place to sleep. With a quality pick, you can get years of fantastic use out of it and it can be a worthwhile investment. With a variety of options on the market, you can have your pick of frame, style, and color.

Read more:

In the market for a product that works in an RV or camper and looking for the right mix of convenience and comfort? Whether you travel frequently or take one or two trips a year, it is possible to get a lot of mileage out of a great product. While RV products aren’t always known for comfort, we have selected a handful of picks that could lead to your best night’s sleep on the road.

Many people have chosen to make RVing a lifestyle. If that is you, do not plan on sacrificing support and the adequate rest your body needs. Instead, pick the right type of material in the size you need, at the appropriate firmness level, and you may never want to go back to your bed at home!

Smart Mattress

The internet has made its way into nearly every corner of our lives, and it seems only natural that it would find its way to your new mattress. Those looking for cutting-edge technology, even when they sleep, have a host of new options—with more cropping up every day!

There are several new features common to what we expect from wellness wearables, such as health monitoring and sleep activity tracking. The idea behind a smart bed is that “knowledge is power” and the more you know about the way you breathe, sleep, and regulate your own body’s temperature, the more optimized your sleep experience can become.

Some smart mattresses are even moving beyond simple monitoring and are incorporating features that can adjust your bed’s temperature or even start brewing your coffee. How cool is that?

Customizable

Depending on a number of factors ranging from age to body shape to health conditions, you may find your sleep needs are highly specific, making it difficult to narrow down the correct mattress for your body without making significant compromises.

These compromises can be compounded if you sleep with a partner who has different preferences. A top customized mattress, especially one with a split feel or firmness makes it different on both sides. This may be something to consider if this sounds like you.

A number of different brands approach firmness and feel from a more individualized approach and can customize things such as firmness, responsiveness, and weight capacity to each customer. Several up and coming brands can be flipped or adjusted at home, without requiring the additional purchase of a topper or another additional layer.

Having a bed that can adjust with you is a huge advantage because so much in our life can change over the lifespan of a mattress, which can be decades long. Weight gains or losses, pregnancy (see our top picks), injuries, or the natural aging process can all change our mattress needs and if your mattress can change with you, you know you’ve made a solid investment.

Top Mattresses By Sleeping Position

When choosing a new bed, many people’s main consideration is the sleeping position and finding the ideal firmness and type for their preferred position. There are three main ones, so let’s see our top mattress picks for each position.

Back Sleepers

Contrary to belief, only 15% of the population are dedicated back sleepers. For some types of people this can even be a more healthy position to rest in. When it comes to firmness,medium/medium-firm works very well here.

You can go a bit more on a firm side but going with softer feel can cause the bed to “hug” too much, which could cause pain in the long run if the spine falls out of alignment. As far as materials, foam, latex, or innerspring are great, but you may want to make sure to choose a product with good cooling properties. There is no single “best” product here, since a lot of this is up to personal preference.

Side Sleepers

Side sleeping is pretty common, and it is generally considered healthy and good for your spine and back. Although you won’t likely have the problem of heat and snoring, the main problem you may face is that firmer beds can cause shoulder and hip pain due to increased pressure.

If you prefer this position, try to aim for a medium or softer product as it can contour and adapt to your body, causing pressure relief where needed.

Stomach Sleepers

Although preferred by many, sleeping on your stomach can be considered harmful in many cases. But, if you prefer this position, you can make your sleeping experience much more pleasant by choosing the proper bedding.

Support is the number one concern for you here and choosing a firmer, comfortable mattress tends to be the best choice. If you choose plush products, your spine could curve, causing pain after some time.

Foam-based beds with firm feel are preferred by many, but a good innerspring or hybrid, and even latex, can also serve you well, too. One thing to note is that you will most likely need a thinner pillow than normal to make your spine as straight as possible.

Combination Sleepers

Very few individuals are committed to just one sleep position and prefer to switch back and forth between two or three favorites throughout the night. Whatever your preferred combination is, you’re going to need a versatile pick.

Combination sleepers should look for beds that advertise “universal” feels, especially ones that can offer a Medium-Firm feel as these typically offer the right blend of pressure-relieving comfort and support to accommodate most positions. You might also shop brands designed to help you reposition so that effort to roll over doesn’t wake you in the middle of the night.

Top Rated Mattresses for Specific Needs

Every one of us has specific needs, and in some cases, we are looking for a bed specially designed to meet them.

Let’s face it, one of the biggest selling points for a mattress is that it’s “good for sex.”

But what does that mean? What’re the criteria that make it good or help it obtain a good rating? A short list includes:

  • Responsiveness
  • Great Bounce
  • Low Noise
  • Edge Support
  • Comfort (you still need to sleep on it after)

Traditionally, memory foam wasn’t considered very good for making love since it didn’t have almost any bounce and it had a slow response. Advanced and custom foams solved this issue, but latex and coil beds can be much better for this purpose, although picking this type can mean noise reduction. It all depends on what you value.

Heavy People

Larger or heavier people have slightly different needs. Due to more intense pressure caused by weight, you may need a thicker and slightly firmer mattress than normal. Cooling and edge support can also become an issue.

Usually, you will want to aim for 12” or thicker, but advanced foam constructions can provide the same level of comfort and support at 9-10”. Just avoid lower-end products as these will usually sag under pressure.

A quality foam or innerspring/foam hybrid is considered ideal since it provides good cooling and support while it still contours and hugs the sleeper’s body, providing pressure point relief.

Cooling

For many people,the main reason for buying a new bedis that they want to sleep cooler. Just ten years ago, this wasn’t even a consideration. Today, it’s one of the main key features.

Different materials have different heat retention properties, and some of them sleep considerably cooler than others.

Heat Retention Graphic – How cool or hot each type of mattress typically sleeps.

Traditional foams will sleep much hotter than coil or latex, and most hybrids were made to sleep cool. With the invention of the gel layer, even foam products are now much better when it comes to heat distribution.

A good rule of thumb is if you tend to sleep hot, don’t go with cheaper memory-foam products. Either go with a hybrid, gel, open cell, phase changing material, or something aerated.

Couples

Sleeping with your partner in the same bed can be challenging if you have different preferences. Most couples have reported the following issues:

  • Motion transfer– If one partner is a restless sleeper, a bed with lower motion isolation means the other one may suffer and wake up all the time. Older steel coil construction often higher transfer but newer pocket coil designs perform much better.
  • Different firmness preferences– If you enjoy a firm feel while your partner sleeps on his/her side and enjoys a softer feel, most couples will compromise for a medium firmness product. Many products can have split firmness (one side is firmer than the other), or you can opt for 2x Twin XL in a King size frame.
  • It has to be good for sex– Obviously, you don’t want to grab a new bed and make love on the sofa.

Adjustable

With the invention of new and lighter materials, adjustable beds are now more affordable, durable, and comfortable. The main feature is that you can adjust it any way you want. This is especially useful for certain conditions such as back pain and snoring. Back in the day, this type of bed was used primarily by older adults, but these days almost anyone can use it.

You can use it for an afternoon nap, relaxation time or when watching TV. “Zero gravity” body position allows for natural spine alignment for better pain relief. The downside is that some models haven’t historically looked so nice (which is definitely changing) and there are mechanisms that have the potential to break after some time. It’s still a fantastic choice for may suffering from lumbar or neck stiffness or pain.

Firm Feel

If you have already decided which type of mattress and firmness level you would prefer and you know what kind of sleeper you are, you just need to select the right product. You can opt for firmer products if you are a back or stomach sleeper or a heavier person looking for more support and less sagging.

It should help keep your spine from arching and your pelvis from sinking too deep. Mixing firm support with a pillow top or comfort layer can make the evening even more cozy.

Soft Feel

Your body and weight will play an important role in the overall feel. If you are a heavier person, you will generally need a firmer mattress to get the same feel as someone who is much lighter than you.

Support is absolute key for any mattress ever, but something that feels like a rock can cause unnecessary pain in the long run. Higher end soft feel beds can also provide enough support, cooling, and help with pressure points.

In most cases,side sleepers will want a softer feel, and a great example is memory foam. However, you probably will not want a softer feel if you are a strict stomach sleeper.

You can also alter the feel based on the frame. For example, a platform bed may seem a bit firmer than a more flexible base.

Athletes

For the athletes and active folks among us, those who train and want to make the most out of every minute of the day, whether awake or asleep, there are products with innovative materials and features that can help to boost recovery. And boosting recovery may even lead to an increase in overall performance.

While some brands tout specific gains for athletes, there are also other quality products that can offer everything from customization and cooling (perhaps good for some with high metabolisms!). Celliant, a material gaining popularity in this space and is currently undergoing testing, could help to turn the body’s energy back into infrared light for deeper rest and recovery.

Light Sleepers

For light sleepers, sharing a bed with a restless child, partner, or pet can be misery if you don’t manage to select the right bed. Looking for the right set of features can help to ensure you are not jostled, shaken, or poked awake in the middle of the night by a stray elbow.

Brands with excellent motion isolation, such as hybrids with pocketed coils or all-foam constructions, can greatly reduce the amount of vibration that can transfer from a partner’s movement to your space. Also, brands with excellent edge support can increase the bed’s usable space so that you’re not crowded into the middle of the bed where you might feel movements more acutely.

Recommended Beds for Specific Medical Conditions

Specific conditions require different bedding materials and firmness levels. We researched and selected the most common conditions that can be helped, or perhaps in some cases prevented, by using a proper mattresses.

Back Pain

If you are suffering from back pain, nighttime can be one of the only part of the day that brings relief. It’s usually a secondary result of some other underlying condition or disease such as arthritis, scoliosis, or kyphosis.

When it comes to sleep, the most important thing is support. Note thatfirmer doesn’t equal more support, nor does it mean that softer feel bed is less supportive. Comfort is an important factor because you want those pressure points to rest during the night and proper spine alignment is a must.

Arthritis

Arthritis is a serious medical condition followed by joint swelling, stiffness, and pain. The most problems occur when you are trying to sleep. There are two types:

  • Osteoarthritis– Caused by bone friction due to breakdown of cartilage
  • Rheumatoid arthritis– Inflammatory disease that causes uncomfortable swelling and fluid around the joints

If you consider different types, coil or high-end foam mattresses are recommended for back sleepers with a medium-firm feel. Side sleepers will prefer plush products with a bit more hug.

Neck Pain

Many people experience it at least once in their lives. Waking up with neck pain once in awhile is not a cause for concern. But, if the problem persists, and if the condition drags out for months, first you need to get a doctor’s exam and if everything is okay, consider adapting or changing your bedding.

Most of the time pillows are the cause, but saggy and old mattresses can also cause neck stiffness. The most important thing is that your sleep surface supports your spine and neck (you can see some of the top rated picks for those who deal with neck pain). Without enough support, even firm beds will cause problems.

Sleeping on your stomach with a thick pillow is also one of the major causes of this issue. In some cases, you can even consider sleeping without a pillow.

Hip Pain

Hip pain, much like your back, can indicate a series of other issues and conditions. Make sure to check everything with your doctor before purchasing a new bed.

You will most likely experience this issue if you are sleeping on your side on a firm bed without a proper hug. Traditional coil beds are something to look out for if you are suffering from hip pain, but hybrids and foam products may be perfect due to increased contouring to your body.

Fibromyalgia

People suffering from this chronic autoimmune disease can experience severe fatigue, insomnia, and constant feel of tiredness. Other common symptoms are sleep apnea and restless leg syndrome.

A combination of exercise, medications, and a proper sleeping surface can help relieve symptoms. Pressure points are very important here, and you will need a bed with enough support while providing good cushioning and contouring.

Snoring

Not only that it’s annoying for your partner, but snoring can also lead to more serious conditions. Slightly elevating your head while sleeping can reduce snoring and increase air flow. But, it’s not healthy for your spine and neck to sleep on a thick pillow in some positions.

Sleep Number created a technology that allows you to adjust the height of your bed with a push of a button, which can really help. Other manufacturers followed, and nowadays you have many adjustable beds to choose from. We have created a complete article with the roundup of the best anti snore beds, so make sure to check them out.

Sleep Apnea

The population of people suffering from sleep apnea is growing every day as more individuals are going to their doctor seeking relief from symptoms of snoring and overwhelming fatigue. If not properly managed, this condition can lead to much more serious health conditions, such as high blood pressure, heart attack, or stroke.

Though only your doctor can best advise how to manage this condition, a good mattress may also help alleviate symptoms and improve your rest. Mattresses that can accommodate side or stomach sleeping while properly aligning your spine may help your airways remain clear. Options compatible with adjustable bases may also open up more effective sleep positions.

Insomnia

There are many factors that can keep you awake at night and contribute to insomnia, and talking to your doctor is the best way to help examine your symptoms. However, if you suspect your mattress might be to blame, there are several features to look for to help alleviate the most common forms of night-time restlessness.

First, you may try shopping for picks that offer exceptional pressure relief as uncomfortable pressure points can inhibit good circulation and keep you awake. Also, if temperature is an underlying cause, you may look for options designed to regulate their own temperature so you don’t overheat.

Allergies and Asthma

Exposure to molds, mildews, dust mites, or chemical irritants can all trigger an allergic reaction or an asthma attack. Traditional innersprings can create a haven for dust accumulation, and old-fashioned memory foams can be a hotbed for unwanted chemicals. Thankfully, more modern companies have come up with special features that can reduce exposure to unwanted triggers.

Look for foams that are certified to the CertiPUR-US® or comparable standards and more eco-friendly materials that can cut down on chemical treatments. Pocketed coils, foams infused with antimicrobial additives like copper, graphite, or green tea, and all-natural latex beds can all help reduce the likelihood of an allergic reaction.

Hot Flashes and Menopause

Hot flashes may be inevitable, but a company that has gone the extra mile to develop cooling technologies for their mattress could help prevent the process from ruining your night’s sleep. You should look for beds that specifically target breathability as this can help keep the mattress cooler and drier while you sleep. When you do wake up sweaty, you will want a bed that can quickly dry out and help heat to dissipate.

Beds with coil systems allow for a lot of airflow that can help regulate temperature, and in general, these mattresses usually sleep the coolest. Latex can also be an excellent choice as it is a temperature neutral material that also allows for a lot of air to flow through.

If you’re in love with memory foam, many modernized memory beds have updated their foams to help prevent overheating. Moisture-wicking fabrics, phase change technology, or cooling gels infused through your foams could keep the heat from getting stuck in the mattress right up next to your body.

Osteoporosis

Pressure points are not ideal for any sleeper but can be absolutely agonizing for someone living with and learning to manage a condition like osteoporosis. Ongoing research shows that a light exercise program (designed by a health care provider) can help strengthen your muscles and protect deteriorating bones, but you probably won’t feel up to exercising if you aren’t able to get the proper amount and quality of rest.

You will want to look for a mattress that can mold to your shape so that pressure points melt away while still providing the amount of support you need to keep your spine in a straight line. Beds with zoning in them can help you achieve this balance by varying support depending on the weights of different parts of your body.

Mattresses that can help you stay cool can also minimize tossing and turning that can be exceptionally painful for folks with this condition. Though traditional memory foams do a great job with pressure relief, they can often sleep really hot. Newer innovations with these materials and infusions of gels and copper can help carry heat away so that your rest remains comfortable and cool.

Restless Leg Syndrome

Research has shown that improving the quality of your rest can reduce the symptoms of Restless Leg Syndrome. Though only a doctor can provide the proper intervention for this condition, a mattress uniquely suited to your needs may help improve your sleep and allow your muscles a greater opportunity to relax. Improving your sleep hygiene could potentially go a long way towards improving the outcomes for a number of different health conditions.

Ideally, you’ll want a bed that decreases pressure points and cradles your body so that restlessness is kept at a minimum. Memory foam or latex may be a good choice for that, as well as hybrids that include these materials in their comfort layers. As an added bonus, foams could help isolate motion that results from your moving legs and prevent it from disturbing your sleep partner.

Choosing a mattress may be up to your individual taste and what suits you best. Ideally, your back should remain comfortably aligned and you shouldn’t feel any pressure. Your individual body type will dictate a lot of what kind of bed will best be able to manage your comfort.

How are mattress rated

If you dread a trip to Mattress Firm or Macy’s, realize that you have more options than ever before—department and specialty stores are no longer the default destination for mattress shopping. Great mattresses at fair prices can be found at warehouse clubs and through online retailers—and the competition is only getting more intense.

We test queen-size mattresses (60 inches wide by 80 inches long) because they’re the most common size purchased. (For your reference, the other standard dimensions are king, 76×80 inches; California king, 72×84; full, or double, 53×75; and twin, 38×75.)

We subject each mattress to a battery of tests, including running a nearly 310-pound roller over each one 30,000 times to simulate eight to 10 years of use. Still, there’s much to know even before you start shopping. Here’s your path to a good night’s sleep.

Find the Best Mattress for Any Sleeper

Compare the Types

If you’re shopping for a new mattress, you could be overwhelmed by the variety of choices and prices, ranging from too-low-to-believe to astronomical. But there’s good news: Our years of testing have shown that, whichever type you choose, you only need to spend around $1,000 for a comfortable, supportive mattress. Here are the major types you’ll see:

Foam Mattresses

Though many manufacturers use polyurethane to create their foam layers, some might use latex as well and we note which mattresses have latex in our features tab. Some mattresses include both. Memory foam softens when you lie on it and soon molds to your body. Once you get up, it springs back to its original shape. Some foam mattresses require some effort to change position.

Innerspring Mattresses

Adjustable Air Mattresses

Interactive Video Guide

For more, watch our interactive video. You can skip to chapters on the different types of mattresses, tips for test-driving a mattress, and more.

Mattress Myths

Common claims that haven’t held up in our tests:

The More Coils, the Better
The better innerspring models we test have 600 to 1,000 coils. But even if one mattress has more coils than another, the coils could be made of thinner-gauge metal. You’ll also hear about coil variations such as Bonnell (hourglass type), continuous wire, and individually pocketed springs. None of those is inherently superior.

Gel Provides a Cooler Sleep
More than half our innerspring mattresses (noted in our mattress ratings) have a layer of gel-infused foam that’s claimed to provide a cooling effect, though it’s worth noting that 10 percent of the mattresses with a gel-infused layer still retain warmth. Overall, our tests have shown that innerspring mattresses containing gel did tend to sleep slightly cooler, but the reverse was true with gel-infused foam beds.

Forget About Comparison Shopping

If you like a mattress at one store and ask elsewhere for something similar, you’re likely to be steered toward a same-brand mattress claimed to have the same construction, components, and firmness. Mattress makers offer some lines nationally, but when those brands are sold through major chains such as Macy’s or Mattress Firm, they’re typically exclusive to those chains. And manufacturers don’t publish a directory of comparable mattresses. So use our ratings as a guide, and insist on the precise make and model that scored well in our tests. Also check our ratings of mattress brands and stores, based on subscriber surveys.

Shopping Tips

Lie Down
If possible, lie on any mattress that you’re considering. Wear loose clothes, and shoes you can slip off. Make yourself comfortable, and shoo away the salesperson if you’re feeling pressured. Salespeople should expect you to take your time. Spend at least 5 or 10 minutes on each side and on your back (your stomach, too, if that’s a preferred sleeping position). Panelists who took beds home for a month-long trial rarely changed the opinion they formed after the first night. Shopping online or at a warehouse club? Tryouts aren’t usually an option, so checking return policies before you buy is extra-important.

Check Return Policies
Make sure the store offers a full refund or credit toward another mattress. Return periods, often called “comfort guarantees,” range from a couple of weeks to 120 days. Some retailers, including Macy’s and Sears, charge a 15 percent restocking fee. Some sellers provide free pickup if you want a refund or an exchange, but otherwise, you’ll have to pay for it—or cart the mattress to the store. Macy’s, for example, charges an $85 pickup fee. And you’ll be responsible for any damage.

Try to Haggle
Once you’ve settled on a model, try to bring the price down. Many businesses, such as warehouse clubs, have fixed prices and won’t budge. But for retailers that do negotiate—particularly specialty chains—huge markups allow them to lower prices by 50 percent or more during their frequent sales. Our recommendation: Any time of year, insist on a sale price you’ve seen for the mattress you know you want, and don’t be afraid to walk out if you feel you’re getting a raw deal. While it’s a little tougher to negotiate online, there are still ways to save.

Don’t Be Bullied Into Buying a Box Spring
You might not need it. If your box spring isn’t broken and is still structurally sound, consider keeping it and saving money (roughly $150 to $300 for a queen-size). One caveat: Some brands require you to buy their box spring to receive full warranty coverage. Many foam manufacturers recommend a platform base or strong slatted wood foundations.

Understand the Warranty
It can range from 10 to 25 years and covers only manufacturing defects such as sagging and loose or broken coil wires. Coverage is frequently prorated, meaning that it decreases over time.

On Delivery Day
Never accept delivery without inspecting the mattress (and the box spring, if you buy one) for stains and other damage. Also be sure that the mattress has a label that states “all-new material” before you send the driver on his way. If it’s not there, refuse delivery. And keep it on afterward in case you have to file a warranty claim in the future. If you bought a bed-in-a-box, inspect the mattress as soon as you unroll it. Call customer service immediately if something appears to be wrong with the mattress or if it’s dirty. Take a few photos with your smartphone in case the customer service representative asks for proof of the damage.

Need a new set of sheets for your new mattress? Check our sheets buying guide and ratings to find out how we rate and review cotton sheets.

Add a Comment: